Calc III Materials
Below is a collection of resources I've obtained over the years for specifically
the subject of multivariate calculus, Calc III. This includes material
I've made myself, resources I've taught from, and resources that I think are
particularly helpful (note the last two are not always the same thing). This
list is collected partly for my own notes, but anybody perusing this page is free
to use them as they see fit - I've annotated the list so that it's easier to find
the best source for the reader's purposes.
Resources
Online resources
Here are a couple nice online resources one could us in learning
calculus. I often go to these when I need an immediate answer
to a question, or a quick practice problem. Online text-based
sources are often less dense than a book, and so are good places
to review. The visual sources and lecture series, meanwhile, can
be very good for gaining intuition on their topics. They're low
on practice problems and proofs, but high on helping to visualize
concepts. These items are listed perhaps in order of most useful
downwards.
- First and foremost, Paul's
Online Math Notes. This is a wonderful resource for practice problems,
reviews, cheat sheats, notes, example exercises, and whatever else you might
need. It also contains the same volume of information for the classes taken
before Calc III as well, in case you need a review of any of them. There is
also material on differential equations for those taking that course. As a
TA I've often used it for practice problems, or to look up a minor detail
that escapes me in conversation. Unfortunately it doesn't include material
on linear algebra; unlike here at Georgia Tech that course is often taken
after differential equations. Still, for any other pre-proofs course this
is an incredible resource to know about and use.
- Another good resource is the playlists on Calc I/II and Linear Algebra
by YouTuber 3blue1brown.
This isn't a written source, so it doesn't have as many nice materials as
Paul's notes. Instead, it's a lecture series, so it focuses on giving a
vocal and visual experience which is conducive to the viewer's understanding.
In this, 3blue1brown excels. He is a wonderful lecturer with great exposition,
and he also gives viewers plenty of chances to try and figure things out for
themselves before giving an explanation ("pause and ponder", as he says). The
visuals he uses are also top-notch. His custom Python library gives him a lot
of control over the visuals he uses on screen, and he uses it well. I've often
said that I didn't truly understand eigenvalues and eigenvectors until I
watched his video on that subject. He hasn't done a video series on Calc III yet,
but the series he has does give a lot of good intuitive grounding on the other
classes, and so are very good for students who are looking for a better
understanding of prior material before going into Calc III.
- One other video series to consider is Khan
Academy's series on Calc III. I haven't watched this myself; in this
case I defer to the expertise of 3blue1brown, who recommends this series,
as well as the general popularity of Khan Academy.
Books
Here is a list of books I consider to be more or less useful
resources to learn Calc III from. As with most subjects,
each of these books provides a comprehensive study of its
subject. In the case of Calc III, many books also cover the
other calculus courses, and at least one in this list will
in fact cover more than that. I have organized this list
roughly in reverse order of difficulty, with the small caveat that
any books that don't at least cover the other calculus
courses are near the end of the list.
- The three "standard" books I know of are the book by Thomas, which is used
here at Georgia Tech; the book by Stewart; and the book by Larson, Ron, and Edwards.
Each of these are roughly equivalent in that they cover about the same material in
about the same way. All three are roughly 16 chapter books which cover all three
calculus courses within their content. I view Stewart as perhaps the most informative
yet dry of them, but it was also the first book I used, and its examples of
interesting polar-coordinate graphs can be cited as the source which sparked
my interest in math. Larson I'm most familiar with, but I don't have much
to say about it. Perhaps that it's a bit easier of a read than Stewart.
Thomas is the book we use at Georgia Tech, and that is very nearly all I know
about it. Again, these books are all roughly equivalent. They all contain
a wealth of information done informally (relative to the other books I give below)
and have a ton of computational practice problems for every section. All are good
places to start with Calc III.
- A slightly more advanced book of similar content is Marsden's series on calculus.
This series is not usually compiled as one book, but the three volumes do still
cover all three courses. This book is more advanced in its choice of topic and
its selection of practice problems. Both are more theoretical, but not too much so.
The problem selection is a mix of standard computation and harder proofs/word problems.
To give an example on the content choice, the Calc III book describes equations
for all possible conics rather than just the standard formulae, which
are aligned with the standard bases. Similarly, Marsden's book is the one
which I referenced in writing my notes on the arc length parameter below.
In this sense, Marsden's content is a bit more involved, but not
horribly so. You can still expectto learn most of the same
material as the above three books from reading it.
- I will recommend Apostol's calculus series here as well.
I don't know it very well, but it has been recommended to me
several times by people with a heavy interest in mathematics;
for that reason I suspect it to be even more advanced than
Marsden. Content-wise, in two volumes Apostol covers all of
calculus and most of linear algebra, as well as an introduction
to differential equations. The problems are again a combination
of proofs and computational problems, though it is more
explicit in its request for proofs than Marsden. For an
advanced student, this is likely a good choice of book.
- A very interesting book for Calc III will serve as my
departure from books which provide the full content of
the calculus series. This book is Clark Bray's Multivariable
Calculus. Two things really stand out to me in this book.
The first is its pictures, which are hand-drawn on
perhaps a tablet, and so give the book a very real,
personal feel. The text supports this, as it's written
in an informal, friendly style. The hand-written nature
of the drawings is also useful, in the sense that the
book contains plenty of sample drawings to give a feel
for how to make drawings yourself. The trade-off,
of course, is that they are less exact; another book
might be better for finding perfect drawings.
The other benefit of this book is its handling of
vector analysis, i.e., the final chapter of any calculus
book. The book doesn't try to be advanced, but rather to
provide a flavor for the extremely interesting advanced
topics without bogging the reader down with all the details.
Specifically, this means there are few proofs in the text.
However, these are replaced with intuitive descriptions
of powerful theorems in differential geometry, thinly
masquerading as the standard topics in Calc III. There are
some incredible resources within that chapter specifically
coming from this approach, which I have used as references
occasionaly due to their usefulness. I would highly
recommend this book for an interesting take on Calc III.
- I list this final book for the sake of completion.
I have taught from it, but I would be careful about choosing
to learn the subject directly from it. The book is Spivak's
Calculus on Manifolds, and it discusses multivariable
calculus at nearly the highest level one could possibly
discuss it. This includes full analytic treatments
of both differentiation and integration, as well as the
subjects of differential forms and manifolds. It is terse
and proof-heavy, and the exercises are proof-based questions
given as rigorously as possible. There are very few computational
questions. If you are already accustomed to proofs and are
looking for a challenging exposition on multivariable calculus,
then I would recommend this book; however, for a student near
the level of a more standard Calc III course, I would probably
consider this a bit too advanced and suggest a different book
on this list.
Writings
The following are materials I have made myself. Often they are
supplementary materials I have written to answer questions from
students in a Calc III course. They are not all necessary for
a basic understanding of the subject; in the case that they are
not, they provide supplementary information which I found
interesting or pertinent enough to share. These are written in
LaTeX, listed in reverse chronological order, and may be
downloaded by clicking the title. Abstracts detailing the
contents follow.
- Regarding the Arc
Length Parameter, Jan. 2022. We develop the theory of
parametrization and use this explore the arc length parameter
of a position vector-valued function .
We consider the relationship between this and the position
vector, and describe a way in which the arc length parameter
can be used in calculations.